III. ECONOMIC TRENDS AND OUTLOOK MAJOR TRENDS AND OUTLOOK In 1993 the Colombian economy registered real GDP growth of 5.3%, up from 3.5% in 1992. These results came as a pleasant surprise to government economists who, as late as October 1993, had been predicting growth of between 4-and-4.5%. The economic liberalization reforms which began in 1991 continued to spur the importation of large amounts of capital goods which have improved efficiency and have made Colombia's industrial sector more competitive in global markets. Colombia's large holdings of foreign reserves have kept the peso strong, and the nation's exporters have been vocal in requesting the government to depreciate the currency more quickly. The outlook for Colombian exports in 1994 has brightened somewhat, thanks to sharp increases in world coffee prices, and to a lesser extent, higher prices for petroleum, coal and ferronickel. In the second quarter of CY1994 government officials were predicting GDP growth for 1994 of 5.5-6% with inflation coming down to 19%. Increased government revenues from privatizations in 1994 plus cutbacks in government spending indicates that Colombia will run a 2-3% fiscal surplus in 1994. Private economists are somewhat less sanguine than their government counterparts about 1994 economic performance. They foresee GDP growth of about 5%, neither a fiscal deficit nor a surplus and inflation of 22% (based mainly on the unexpectedly high inflation rates recorded the first four months of 1994). PRINCIPAL GROWTH SECTORS Sectors which recorded strong growth in 1993 included construction (up 9.5%), financial services (up 6.7%) and transportation and communications (up 6.1%). The public utilities sector, while accounting for only 1% of GDP, grew by 12.8% because of the rebound in electricity production following the 1992 drought which cut deeply into hydroelectric output. The manufacturing sector, which accounted for 21% of GDP, grew by 1.8% in 1993, down from the 4.9% growth it recorded in 1992. The principal reason for the modest growth seen in 1993 was the 16% decline in coffee processing, an activity which grew by 31% in 1992. The manufacturing sector, excluding coffee processing, grew by 5% last year. Leading manufacturing sub-sectors were those associated with the diminished, but still strong growth in construction: glass, cement and other non-metallic minerals, plastics and ceramics. The automotive industry showed significant growth in 1993 as domestic demand for cars soared. Assembly of automobiles and industrial vehicles during the first 8 months of 1993 was 73% above the corresponding period in 1992. Some manufacturing sub-sectors did not prosper in 1993. Textiles, paper, industrial chemicals, tobacco and leather lagged because of competition from legal imports and contraband and from a revalued peso, which diminished the competitiveness of such exports. The extractive industries (oil, natural gas, coal and other minerals) registered growth of 0.3% in 1993. The nearly stagnant performance in this sector was mainly attributable to declines in production of iron ore, gold and silver. There were some bright sides to this sector in 1993: Colombia's giant Cerrejon open-pit coal mine, a joint Exxon-Colombia venture, boosted production by 16% thanks to increased demand in the U.S. due to a major coal miners strike. Production of crude oil, natural gas and platinum also rose. Hydrocarbons continue to be the second most important export for Colombia (US752 million in 1993). The petroleum industry is dynamic and its share in the GDP fluctuated around 3.5 percent during 1990-1992, a period lacking new oil deposit developments. In 1993, significant new investments were made in exploration and development at Cusiana and Cupiagua. The projections are that these combined fields hold 1.5 to 2 billion barrels and that these activities will involve investments of around USD 5 billion for development. Total investments in the oil and gas sector may exceed USD 10 billion during the rest of the 1990s, including refineries, storage facilities, and new exploration. Hundreds of millions of dollars have already been invested in this project by BP Exploration, the operator, and Total (France) and Triton Energy (US). Growth in oil and gas production was up 3.2 percent over 1992 in spite of numerous guerilla attacks on the pipelines. These attacks resulted in losses of nearly 115,000 barrels of crude oil. The government put the total cost of these attacks at USD 86 million or equivalent to about 0.2 percent of the national GDP. Agricultural production (which includes livestock, hunting, fishing and forestry) grew 2.8% in 1993, despite a decline of 8% in the area cultivated. The improvement resulted from a combination of favorable weather and certain steps taken by the government to help farmers. Among the latter were the government's decision to buy an important percentage of the cotton crop and to reestablish subsidies for cotton exports. The government also bought enough of the rice harvest to keep producer prices at an acceptable level. The situation regarding cotton and rice brightened in late 1993 when international prices for those commodities began to rise. The government announced floor prices for other agricultural products, before planting time, to limit farmers' risks, thereby boosting production. There was little change regarding production of wheat, corn and sorghum. Low international prices coupled with a strengthening peso caused imports of these crops to continue rising. Corn imports exceeded one half million tons in 1993 as they did in 1992. Sorghum producers were adversely affected by continuing low prices for their crop combined with the substitution of yellow corn for sorghum by the concentrates industry. Wheat producers saw some improvement in their lot in 1993 thanks to a domestic agreement between growers and millers. Colombian banana growers saw the price of their product drop nearly 4% in 1993, a development exacerbated by the effective revaluation of the peso. In addition, import restrictions imposed by the European Community on bananas from Latin America, beginning in July 1993, led to a price war in the U.S. market. At the close of 1993 the government's massive plan to refinance the agricultural sector, which was begun in 1993, had shown positive results. A total of US$162 million had been provided to the agricultural sector: US$87 million went to restructure coffee producer credits while US$75 million went into restructuring producer credits for banana growers and other producers. The agricultural sector also looked to certain chapters in the Agrarian Law to provide more, and less expensive, farm credit. This would ease one of the principal problems affecting Colombia's agricultural sector: easy access to institutional credit. Performance in the coffee sector was disappointing in 1993. Production of parchment coffee was down 13.2% compared to 1992 while coffee processing showed a 16.1% decline. Low international coffee prices were exacerbated in Colombia by crop disease. Prices in 1993 ranged from a low of US$.569/pound in April to a high of US$.80 in December. Colombia exported 13.6 million sacks of coffee in 1993, down 18.1% from the 1992 level. Receipts from coffee exports in 1993 totaled US$1,337 million, 6.8% lower than corresponding receipts in 1992. As a consequence of the above, Colombia's National Coffee Fund recorded losses of approximately US$96.4 million, serious, but less than half the nearly US$200 million loss recorded in 1992. The government's domestic coffee policy was strongly criticized by the Colombian Association of Coffee Exporters in November 1993. The association supported the coffee retention quota among producing countries (established in September 1993) as well as the creation of the association of coffee producing countries, but criticized the government for not developing a long-term, stable and sustainable coffee policy. Colombia's public utilities sector recorded growth of 12.8% in 1993. The principal reason for the strong performance was the recovery of electricity production, which was hard hit by a severe drought in 1992. Additional production from new hydro plants as well as construction of thermal plants in 1993 resulted in an adequate supply of electricity for the nation's economy. Electricity rationing, which had caused widespread disruptions to economic and personal activities in 1992, was eliminated in early 1993. Colombia's construction sector posted 9.5% growth in 1993, down slightly from the 11.5% growth it showed in 1992. In response to the ongoing strength shown by this sector, savings and housing corporations (CAVs) channeled US$1.9 billion into it in 1993, a remarkable 93 percent increase over 1992. The bulk of credit went to finance large construction projects (62%) while 38% went to individual projects. Only 3% of total resources went to finance social housing projects (housing units valued at US$13,000 or less). The CAVs plan to lend US$2.2 billion in 1994 and construction growth should reach 6% in 1994.. GOVERNMENT ROLE IN THE ECONOMY Since taking office in August 1990, the Gaviria Administration has undertaken a program of sweeping economic modernization and liberalization. A package of legislation enacted since the end of 1990 revised Colombia's trade, financial and tax laws, the exchange regime, and the labor code. It also eliminated almost all prior import license requirements; simplified import/export procedures; established a free market exchange regime; liberalized foreign investment; clarified the rules to allow creation of new financial entities; and reoriented tax collections from external to domestic sources. Other reforms created a more autonomous Central Bank, restructured the export promotion agency into an export-import bank, and created two new ministries: foreign trade and the environment. These measures were complemented with decrees which sharply cut tariff duties and strengthened the financial system by reducing forced investments and increasing capital requirements. Colombia's Constitution was rewritten in 1991. Despite fears of leftist influence, the rewritten Constitution preserves the traditional market-oriented economy based on private ownership. The government pushed ahead with its privatization program in 1993. Lengthy preparations for the privatization of the Banco de Colombia bore fruit early in 1994 when the bank was sold to private bidders for US$509 million. The government subsequently divested itself of holdings in two other financial institutions, Corpavi and Bancoldex, and plans to liquidate its holdings in Banco Popular and Banco del Estado before the end of July 1994. The privatization of Colombia's ports was concluded in March 1994 when Colombia's President handed over the Pacific port of Buenaventura to the private sector. Buenaventura was the last port pending privatization, and it is billed as Colombia's door to the Orient. Colombia turned over cellular telephone operations to private bidders when it awarded the second, and final, round of cellular telephone licenses to joint ventures comprised of public telephone companies and private operators. After having granted the first round of licenses to private operators in January 1994, the stage is now set for the introduction of this service in Colombia during the middle of 1994. Other assets which the government wants to privatize are its 50% percent share in the US$3 billion Cerrejon coal mine and its 48% interest in the Cerromatoso ferronickel mine. The government carried out several other reforms in 1993. By far the largest was the reform of the social security system. In December 1993, after long, heated debates, the social security system was approved by Congress. The Government's monopoly on pension funds and health service through the Social Security Institute (ISS) has been eliminated and the allotment system modified. A dual pension fund system has been approved with contributions going to either a private pension fund or to the ISS. The ISS will continue with its obligations to retired beneficiaries and beneficiaries near retirement. Other beneficiaries can voluntarily transfer to private pension funds under the individual capitalization scheme. The individual capitalization scheme is favored by most Colombians because it promotes personal savings, offers better coverage and overcomes the lack of equity of the current social security system. Under the new pension funds the retirement age will be 62 years for men and 60 for women. BALANCE OF PAYMENTS SITUATION Colombia's balance of trade fell from a US$397 million surplus in 1992 to a US$2,730 million deficit in 1993, the largest trade deficit recorded by Colombia since 1982. Total imports reached US$9,841 million while total exports amounted to US$7,111 million last year. In 1993 imports skyrocketed, growing by 51.1%, reflecting strong domestic demand and the maturing of the nation's economic liberalization program. Export growth was up only 2.9% 1992. Although much blame for the weak export performance has been placed on the appreciation of the peso, the drop in traditional exports (coffee and oil) was also a major factor. Colombia's major trading partner is the U.S., which purchased 39.9% of Colombia's exports and supplied 32.8% of its imports in 1993. Other important trading partners are Venezuela, Japan, Germany and Brazil. Colombia's major exports continue to be coffee, petroleum, coal, ferronickel and non-traditional exports such as cut flowers, semi-precious stones, sugar and tropical fruits. The value of non-traditional exports rose by 11.8% in 1993, thanks largely to a 118% increase in the value of mineral exports and a 10% rise in the value of industrial exports. Non-traditional exports accounted for 56% of all Colombian exports in 1993. Coffee exports, which in the 1960s accounted for 60% of export earnings, represented 16% of total exports in 1993, a clear indication of the success Colombia has had in diversifying its export base. The volume of coffee exports dropped 16% in 1993 and the value of those exports was down 9.5%. Crop disease and weak incentives to coffee growers were the main reasons for the declines. Petroleum and petroleum derivatives exports were down 5.2% in 1993 even though daily production rose by 3.4% to 453,000 barrels/day. The nearly 10% decline in world oil prices was responsible for last year's decline in petroleum export earnings. Nevertheless, petroleum exports totaled US$1.3 billion in 1993, making it the single most valuable export category from Colombia. Coffee had held that title until the early 1990s. Export revenues from coal exports amounted to US$567 in 1993, 2.1% above the 1992 figure. Seventy-five percent of coal exports last year came from the Cerrejon mine in Guajira Department. Imports showed a 51.1% growth as the government's economic liberalization program shifted into high gear. Imports of capital goods amounted to US$3.8 billion in 1993, a 75.7% increase. Consumer goods' imports totaled US$1.7 billion last year, up 82.3% over 1992. About two-thirds of the consumer goods' imports were classified as durable goods. Imports of intermediate goods, mostly for industry, totaled US$4.2 billion, a 26.2% increase from 1992. In 1993, the United States posted a US$395 million trade surplus with Colombia, while in contrast, in 1992 Colombia ran a US$467 surplus with the United States. This dramatic turnaround in the balance of trade between the two nations was due to rapid growth in U.S. exports. U.S. merchandise exports to Colombia grew 43.3% to US$3.2 billion in 1993. Principal U.S. exports to Colombia in 1993 were boilers and machinery, vehicles (excluding railway), electrical machinery, organic chemicals, plastics and cereals. Colombia is the fifth-largest market for U.S. exports in Latin America. TRADE AND INVESTMENT BARRIERS Import licensing: While all imports must be registered with Colombia's Foreign Trade Institute, all but three percent of 5,162 products are on the free list of imports, and are not subject to licensing or prior approval requirements. Products which still require licensing are generally "sensitive" security or national defense items. The exceptions are poultry meat and certain dairy products which, for phytosanitary reasons, are subject to prior import licenses. Prior import licenses are also required for used trucks, buses, and automobiles; used tires, used clothing, and used textiles, all of which are effectively denied from entry into the country. Import Duties: Colombia's economic liberalization program substantially consolidated and reduced tariff duties. There are presently five tariff levels: 0, 5, 10, 15, and 20 percent. The average tariff duty is now 11.57% ((as of August 1994), compared to 35.5 percent in December 1990). A duty of 0 or 5 percent is levied on raw materials, intermediate and capital goods not produced nationally. If the aforementioned products are produced in Colombia, the duty levied is 10 or 15 percent. A 20 percent duty is levied on most other items, principally final consumer goods. Exceptions to these tariff levels include automobiles (35 and 40 percent), pick-up trucks and jeeps (40 percent) and agricultural products subject to the "price band" flexible tariff system. Other Import Fees: The import surcharge was eliminated in 1992. The VAT, which is levied on imports as well as domestically produced goods, was increased from 12 to 14 percent effective January 1, 1993. Value added taxes on automobiles range from 14 to 35 percent. Services Barriers Royalties: The royalty committee was abolished in 1992. Ceilings on all types of royalty remittances (including film) were eliminated. The only requirement is for royalty contracts to be registered with Colombia's Foreign Trade Institute. Banking: Law 9 and Resolution 49 (January 1991) opened up Colombia's financial sector to foreign investment. The new laws permit foreign investors to own up to 100 percent of financial institutions (the former limit was 49 percent). This liberalization allowed Citibank and Bank of America, for instance, to convert their holdings to 100 percent subsidiaries. It has also allowed several of the weaker banks to become affiliated with more experienced and financially stronger partners, and it has increased competition and technological improvements. U.S. banks enjoy full national treatment in Colombia. Maritime Transportation: The Colombian government eliminated cargo reserves and other restrictions on maritime trade with decree 2327 of October 15, 1991. In addition, maritime tariffs, chartering services and route assignments were deregulated. Insurance: Goods transported within Colombia must be insured by companies with commercial presence in the country. Audiovisual: Colombian law limits broadcast of foreign-produced television programs to not more than 40 percent of air time. Advertising: Colombian law requires at least 50 percent local content. Standards, testing, labeling, and certification: The certificate of origin is not required, except for imports from Latin America Integration Association (ALADI) and Andean Pact member countries. Certain types of imports require permits from specialized agencies in Colombia. For example: some agricultural commodities require phytosanitary certification from the Colombian Agricultural Institute. Imports of foodstuffs, pharmaceutical products, cosmetics and certain other products require a license from the Ministry of Health (these are frequently issued only after protracted delays). Investment Barriers: In 1991, the Andean Pact eliminated the remaining restrictions on foreign investment by adopting Decision 291, which provides equal access by foreign investors to regional trade preferences. Colombia has significantly opened up its economy to foreign investment through new regulations which are based on the principles of national treatment, universality and automaticity for foreign investors. The new regulations also eliminated the ceiling on profit remittances, which previously were limited to 25 percent of registered capital. Remittance taxes will be reduced over the next four years from 20 to 12 percent. Law 9 of 1991, Resolutions 49, 51, 52 and 53 of the Council of Economic and Social Policy and Resolution 57 of the Central Bank are the principal regulations governing foreign investment. They grant national treatment to foreign investors and permit 100 percent foreign ownership in virtually all sectors of the Colombian economy. The few exceptions include national security and the disposal of hazardous waste products. There are also numerous restrictions in the services sector, especially banking and transportation. The Colombian government approved regulations authorizing the operation of country investment funds, permitting foreign capital to invest directly in the Colombian stock markets. Despite these investment reforms, some barriers remain. Investment screening has been largely eliminated, and those mechanisms still in place are generally routine and nondiscriminatory. Prior approval by the National Planning Department for foreign investment is required only for investments a) providing a public service (i.e. energy, water, health, communications), or b) amounting to more than USD 100 million in activities related to mining or petroleum. Investment that entails coverage by international or bilateral insurance/risk protection requires subsequent government notification. The Ministry of Communications must approve investment applications in that sector, and the Ministry of Mines must approve all applications for foreign investment related to hydrocarbons. All foreign investments must be registered with the Central Bank's foreign exchange office within three months in order to assure their right to remit profits. All investors, foreign or domestic, must obtain an operating license from the Superintendent of Companies and register with the nearest Chamber of Commerce. Government Procurement Practices: In June 1993, Decree 222 regulating procurement practices was reformed, attempting to eliminate corruption, to give clarity to public bidding and to impose disciplinary, criminal and civil sanctions for failure to complete projects as scheduled. It allowed the private sector to render public services when the government could not. The law expedited the contracting process and established a single national application format and gave equal treatment to foreign companies on a reciprocal basis. The 20% surcharge for foreign companies was eliminated as well as the obligation for contracting 40% of the contract value with a Colombian firm. Customs Procedures: A new customs law was implemented recently which speeded up the payment of customs duties by allowing payment through local banks and expedited the clearance of imports by reducing documentary requirements. Nevertheless, much more can and should be done to speed the customs clearance process. Colombia intends to adhere to the GATT Customs Valuation Code. LABOR FORCE Urban unemployment in Colombia, as measured by employment data from the country's 7 largest cities, fell to 7.9% at the end of 1993. The unemployment rate at the end of 1992 was 9.9%. This was the best employment data recorded by Colombia in recent times. Bogota recorded the lowest unemployment rate at the end of 1993 (5.8%) among the seven largest cities and Pasto the highest (10.9%). The number of unemployed was cut by 103,000 in 1993, but the number of economically active persons fell by 27,600. Seventy-five thousand new jobs were created in 1993, about one-third the number of new jobs created in 1992. The population of citizens of working age increased by 2.1% in 1993 while the number of economically active persons dropped by .5%. There was an increase of 6.4% in the population of inactive persons in 1993. The bottom line is that the decline in unemployment in 1993 must be tempered by the fact that it came about less as the result of new jobs and more as the result of the reduction in those seeking employment. On January 1, 1994 the Colombian government increased the minimum wage by 21.1% to 98,700 pesos per month (about US$120). About 4 million Colombian workers earn the minimum wage. The government raised the minimum wage by decree because it could not reach agreement with Colombian labor unions. The minimum monthly wage for 1994 is equivalent to US$123. Labor unions had called for a 28% increase but government authorities claimed that the approved 21.1% increase was in line with their macroeconomic goals for 1994. According to the latest Ministry of Labor statistics, there were 886,446 unionized workers organized into 2,435 unions, less than 8% of the total labor force of nearly 13 million. Most unionized workers belong to one- company unions or to professional associations. Strong union traditions persist in the larger industries such as petroleum, coal, cement and textiles. The major agricultural unions are concentrated in the sugar and banana industries.